68 customizable lessons, aligned with National Standards, exams and more.
Read NGPF's school-by-school analysis of financial education in America today
Activities
Advocacy
Behavioral Economics
Best Of
Budgeting
Buying a Car
Career
Checking
Consumer Skills
Credit
Cryptocurrencies
Current Events
Curriculum Announcements
Economics
Entrepreneurship
Edpuzzle
ELL Resources
FinCap Friday
Gambling and Sports Betting
Insurance
Interactive
Investing
Math
Paying for College
Philanthropy
Podcasts
Press Releases
Professional Development
Question of the Day
Savings
So Expensive Series
Taxes
Teacher Talk
You may be aware of a recent meta-analysis I did with some colleagues—Tim Kaiser, Annamaria Lusardi, and Lukas Menkhoff. We look at all experiments that randomize who did—and did not—receive financial education across every single experiment ever written! On average: financial education improves financial behaviors in a cost-effective way. Figure 3 from the research brief linked above shows that financial education improves behaviors across many domains!
While those findings are exciting for the financial education field, they say very little about what works and for whom. Many of the financial education experiments were done on adult populations, so what can the overall effect tell us about youth?
Well, you’re in luck. There is a much less-publicized study that my colleagues Tim Kaiser and Lukas Menkhoff published in 2020 studying just that! They investigate every experimental or quasi-experimental study—meaning financial education happened either by random assignment or by chance.
What do they find? Financial education improves financial knowledge, with positive effects for elementary, middle, and high school students.
Financial education also improves financial behaviors, though the authors are cautious and note that it’s very hard to measure financial behaviors for younger respondents. People who aren’t yet financially independent have fewer behaviors that can be cleanly measured, and young people often answer surveys in a way that might make their teachers or parents happy.
The intensity of the instruction suggests additional hours of instruction increase financial knowledge, but diminishing returns set in after about 50 hours. The change in financial behavior also exhibits diminishing returns. While duration may increase topics covered, some of these may not directly improve financial knowledge or behavior—particularly if they are too advanced for youth. This model has no way to account for the quality of instruction.
-----------------
Earlier blog post from Dr. Carly Urban: What happens when states guarantee personal finance courses for all high schoolers?
Interactive: Got FOMO (Fear of Missing Out)?
Reading List for July 8-10th, 2022
Question of the Day: How much did Taylor Swift's Eras Tour gross during its two-year, 149 concert run?
Use NGPF's Online Banking Simulation to Bring Real-World Skills Into the Classroom
NEW Activity - MOVE: Interest Rate Ripple Effect (FOMC Press Conference Sep 18, 2024)
Dr. Carly Urban is Associate Professor of Economics at Montana State University, a Research Fellow at the Institute for Labor Economics (IZA), and a research fellow at the TIAA Institute. She has a full page on her website dedicated to financial education research (https://www.carlyurban.com/home/financial-education), where most of her work has been centered on financial education in schools. This research has been published in top academic journals and covered by major news outlets. When she is not working, she usually spends her time adventuring in the mountains with her husband or her dogs, Cannon and Panda.
Join the more than 12,000 teachers who get the NGPF daily blog delivered to their inbox:
MOST POPULAR POSTS
1
2
Get Festive with NGPF Resources and Activities
3
Useful Personal Finance Movies and Documentaries with Worksheets
4
NEW Holiday Personal Finance Posters
5
NEW NGPF Review Materials Released
Before your subscription to our newsletter is active, you need to confirm your email address by clicking the link in the email we just sent you. It may take a couple minutes to arrive, and we suggest checking your spam folders just in case!
Great! Success message here
New to NGPF?
Save time, increase engagement, and teach life-changing financial skills with NGPF’s free curriculum
1.Register for a free TeacherAccount
2.ExploreSemester Course
3.Findstudent favorites
4.LeverageNGPF Academy
Your new account will provide you with access to NGPF Assessments and Answer Keys. It may take up to 1 business day for your Teacher Account to be activated; we will notify you once the process is complete.
Thanks for joining our community!
The NGPF Team
Complete the form below to access exclusive resources for teachers. Our team will review your account and send you a follow up email within 24 hours.
To speed up your verification process, please submit proof of status to gain access to answer keys & assessments.
Acceptable information includes:
Acceptable file types: .png, .jpg, .pdf.
Once you submit this form, our team will review your account and send you a follow up email within 24 hours. We may need additional information to verify your teacher status before you have full access to NGPF.
Take the quiz to quickly find the best resources for you!