68 customizable lessons, aligned with National Standards, exams and more.
Read NGPF's school-by-school analysis of financial education in America today
Activities
Advocacy
Behavioral Economics
Best Of
Budgeting
Buying a Car
Career
Checking
Consumer Skills
Credit
Cryptocurrencies
Current Events
Curriculum Announcements
Economics
Entrepreneurship
Edpuzzle
ELL Resources
FinCap Friday
Gambling and Sports Betting
Insurance
Interactive
Investing
Math
Paying for College
Philanthropy
Podcasts
Press Releases
Professional Development
Question of the Day
Savings
So Expensive Series
Taxes
Teacher Talk
EconExtra is a series of posts that go beyond the textbook, relating current events and recent developments in economics to content standards, and providing resource suggestions to help you incorporate the current events into your lessons.
The Headlines
From Vax-a-Million to Vax and Scratch to Take Your Shot, vaccine-based lotteries and other incentive programs are popping up across the country. Ohio came up with its Vax-a-Million lottery in mid-May to bring up the vaccine numbers. It was the first, with its first winners drawn this week. And it seems to be working:
Since Ohio started the Vax-a-Million lottery earlier this month, the number of residents ages 16 or older who have received at least one dose of the vaccination jumped by 33 percent, The Associated Press reported. The surge in vaccination rates, 55 percent, is even higher for those between the ages of 20 and 49, Slavitt said. (NBC)
New York and Maryland followed a week later, and at this point, a total of at least six states have decided that offering a lottery to vaccinated residents is a great way to get the vaccination numbers up. California’s program is the biggest. The federal government is offering guidance to states on how to use funds from the American Rescue Plan for these to support these efforts. And states and businesses are offering other types of vaccine incentives. (NewsNation) (CNN)
I was chatting with a neighbor the other night, and his comment on the lottery was “I’d like to see the economics behind that decision.” And that was the genesis of this post! His question got me thinking. How would you go about measuring and analyzing the economic benefits of the lottery? How would you compare them to the benefits of other activities, like setting up mobile or mass vaccination sites, expanding testing, or helping hospitals and businesses recover or make Covid-related updates?
At the center of the economic analysis would be assessing the benefit of keeping any individual healthy. In other words, what costs are avoided if people stay healthy?
Ohio Governor DeWine, in his op-ed piece that appeared in the New York Times on Wednesday, did not mention consulting with economists before deciding to go forward with the lottery. It was all about getting the vaccination rates to turn back around, knowing that unless that happened, it would be hard to get anything, including the economy, back to normal. However, in that piece, reference was made to some figures that could help us model the economic impact (more on that below.)
However, behavioral economists HAVE been doing research on vaccine incentives, and lotteries prove to be very effective. It is worth listening to or reading this NPR interview with Katie Milkman, a behavioral economist from the Wharton school. ABC covered the psychology of lotteries as well, and why they work.
Possible Activities
Begin by reading the articles on the various incentive programs and listening to/reading the NPR interview and ABC article on the behavioral aspects.
Discuss the behavioral aspects of the lottery, and how they compare to other incentive schemes. Are lotteries more or less effective than distributing a smaller incentive to everyone? What could make them more effective?
Brainstorm ways to model the economic value of a lottery. The way to do this would be to quantify the savings or costs avoided by not getting sick. For example, the work cited in the DeWine column suggested that the $5.6 million cost of the lottery is equivalent to the cost of caring for 40 critically ill Covid patients. So if the bump in vaccinations prevents 40 people from getting critically ill, the societal cost will be even.
But not everyone gets critically ill. How do we quantify the costs avoided for those who get ill, but not critically?
In terms of extent of costs, you would have to look at some distribution of the severity of the disease, including probability of death and the lifetime earnings lost in that case.
How many cases of Covid averted by the vaccine would it take to be equal to, say, $1,000,000? Then do the rest of the math to measure the success.
The modeling effort may take too much research and time to complete, but thinking through WHAT data you would need and HOW you would make the calculations would be a useful exercise and window into how empirical economic analysis works. At the very least, in years to come, we should be able to look back and better measure the success of these lotteries.
NGPF Podcast: Julie Beckham of Rockland Trust (MA) is Ms. Money & The Coins
Continue Earning Academy Credits This Week Through NGPF On-Demand! (May 31-June 4)
NEW Activity - MOVE: Interest Rate Ripple Effect (FOMC Press Conference Sep 18, 2024)
5 Resources to Decipher the U.S. Debt Clock
Interactive: The Federal Budget in 2023
Beth Tallman entered the working world armed with an MBA in finance and thoroughly enjoyed her first career working in manufacturing and telecommunications, including a stint overseas. She took advantage of an involuntary separation to try teaching high school math, something she had always dreamed of doing. When fate stepped in once again, Beth jumped on the opportunity to combine her passion for numbers, money, and education to develop curriculum and teach personal finance at Oberlin College. Beth now spends her time writing on personal finance and financial education, conducts student workshops, and develops finance curricula and educational content. She is also the Treasurer of Ohio Jump$tart Coalition for Personal Financial Literacy.
Join the more than 12,000 teachers who get the NGPF daily blog delivered to their inbox:
MOST POPULAR POSTS
1
Question of the Day: How much did Taylor Swift's Eras Tour gross during its two-year, 149 concert run?
2
Get Festive with NGPF Resources and Activities
3
Useful Personal Finance Movies and Documentaries with Worksheets
4
NEW Holiday Personal Finance Posters
5
NEW NGPF Review Materials Released
Before your subscription to our newsletter is active, you need to confirm your email address by clicking the link in the email we just sent you. It may take a couple minutes to arrive, and we suggest checking your spam folders just in case!
Great! Success message here
New to NGPF?
Save time, increase engagement, and teach life-changing financial skills with NGPF’s free curriculum
1.Register for a free TeacherAccount
2.ExploreSemester Course
3.Findstudent favorites
4.LeverageNGPF Academy
Your new account will provide you with access to NGPF Assessments and Answer Keys. It may take up to 1 business day for your Teacher Account to be activated; we will notify you once the process is complete.
Thanks for joining our community!
The NGPF Team
Complete the form below to access exclusive resources for teachers. Our team will review your account and send you a follow up email within 24 hours.
To speed up your verification process, please submit proof of status to gain access to answer keys & assessments.
Acceptable information includes:
Acceptable file types: .png, .jpg, .pdf.
Once you submit this form, our team will review your account and send you a follow up email within 24 hours. We may need additional information to verify your teacher status before you have full access to NGPF.
Take the quiz to quickly find the best resources for you!